Press "Enter" to skip to content

Affordability

Money Minute

Can You Really Afford It? A Smarter Way to Make Purchase Decisions in 2025

In today’s economy, “Can I afford this?” isn’t about what you can buy today — it’s about what you’ll still be able to afford tomorrow. This Money Minute walks you through a modern way to think about true affordability.

The Affordability Crisis No One Talks About

One-click shopping, buy-now-pay-later apps, and subscriptions make it easier than ever to say “yes” — but easy doesn’t mean affordable.

Most households now juggle multiple layers of debt: mortgages, student loans, auto payments, credit cards, and recurring subscriptions. Each piece might feel manageable on its own, but together they can quietly erode your financial stability.

The real question isn’t, “Do I have the money today?” It’s: “Will spending this money today limit my options tomorrow?”

What “Affordable” Actually Means

Your bank balance only shows today. Your Debt-to-Income Ratio (DTI) shows whether you can safely take on more tomorrow.

Debt-to-Income Ratio (DTI) = total monthly debt payments ÷ gross monthly income.
  • Under 28%: Excellent — plenty of financial flexibility
  • 28–36%: Manageable — but you’re starting to limit options
  • 36–43%: High risk — one surprise expense could create real strain
  • Above 43%: Danger zone — most lenders see you as overextended

DTI is your starting point. True affordability also factors in emergency savings, retirement contributions, and your ability to handle financial shocks without panic.

The One-Time Purchase Trap

Big one-time buys — laptops, vacations, furniture — feel less risky than ongoing debt, but the math tells a different story.

On a $5,000 monthly income, a $2,000 purchase is 40% of your monthly pay. Even if you pay cash, that one swipe can:

  • Drain your emergency fund
  • Delay investing or debt payoff
  • Reduce your flexibility for months
Guideline: One-time discretionary purchases usually shouldn’t exceed 10–15% of your monthly income — unless your savings are strong.

Remember: every large purchase has an opportunity cost. That $2,000 could be months of retirement contributions, a stronger emergency fund, or breathing room when life throws a curveball.

The Subscription Economy’s Silent Drain

Recurring payments are small on purpose — they want to fly under the radar.

Consider a typical stack:

  • Streaming: $15/month
  • Fitness app: $30/month
  • Meal kit: $120/month
  • Phone plan upgrade: $85/month

Total: $235/month$2,820/year.

Unlike a one-time purchase, subscriptions increase your DTI every single month. They quietly reduce your future options and make it harder to absorb surprises.

How to Know If You Can *Actually* Afford It

A quick framework you can use before almost any purchase.

For One-Time Purchases

  • Calculate the purchase as a % of your monthly income
  • Make sure you’ll still have 3–6 months of expenses in your emergency fund afterward
  • Confirm your current DTI is under 36%
  • Ask: “Will this still feel worth it six months from now?”

For Recurring Payments

  • Add the new payment to your monthly debts and recalculate DTI
  • Keep DTI under 36% (ideally under 28%)
  • Look at the annual cost, not just the monthly
  • Ask if it truly adds value or is just another slow leak

The Real Cost of Financial Stress

Overextension isn’t just a math problem — it’s a mental health problem.

Money stress shows up as anxiety, lost sleep, tension in relationships, and distraction at work. Living paycheck-to-paycheck — even with a good income — keeps your nervous system in “alert” mode.

Smart affordability decisions aren’t about deprivation. They’re about freedom:

  • The freedom to handle an emergency without panic
  • The freedom to say “yes” to an opportunity
  • The freedom to build wealth, not just manage payments

Your Affordability Action Plan

Five simple moves to put you back in control.

  1. Calculate your current DTI. Include rent/mortgage, loans, and minimum card payments.
  2. Audit recurring expenses. Cancel subscriptions you don’t use or truly value.
  3. Prioritize your emergency fund before big, non-essential purchases.
  4. Use the 48-hour rule for larger purchases: wait two days before you buy.
  5. Run the numbers with the Can You Afford It? Calculator before you commit.
Remember: affordability isn’t “Can I buy this?” It’s “Can I buy this and still protect my future self?”

Ready to pressure-test your next purchase? Try the full Affordability Calculator at FiscalInvestor.com/can-you-afford-it and get instant guidance based on your income, debt, and goals.

This article is for educational purposes only and is not individualized financial advice.